India rejects USCIRF remarks on Sharjeel Imam, says the panel has “no locus standi”
Indian Ambassador to the US Vinay Mohan Kwatra said on 13 November that the US Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) has "no locus standi" to judge the constitutional rights of Indian citizens, and asked it to "introspect on its own prejudices". This followed USCIRF's post describing Sharjeel Imam as detained for his religious freedom advocacy.
Why in news
Background: Sharjeel Imam has been booked under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act on allegations of being among the conspirators of the February 2020 Delhi riots, in which 53 people died. India has long described USCIRF as biased and lacking credibility.
Prelims pointers
- USCIRF is a bipartisan US federal advisory body set up under the International Religious Freedom Act, 1998.
- It recommends countries for designation as "Countries of Particular Concern" to the US State Department, but its recommendations are not binding.
- Articles 25 to 28 of the Indian Constitution guarantee freedom of religion.
- The Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 is India's main anti-terror law. Its bail provisions are stricter than ordinary criminal law.
- Kwatra said USCIRF's "partisan, ill-informed" assessments cannot diminish India's constitutional commitment to religious freedom.
Mains angle
India treats external commentary on its internal and judicial matters as interference in sovereignty, especially from bodies it considers biased. At the same time, democratic credibility rests on robust domestic safeguards such as judicial review, speedy trials and fair bail processes. Strong institutions are the best answer to outside criticism.