Government considers withdrawing safe harbour protection for algorithm-driven social media platforms
The Centre is examining whether to remove blanket safe harbour protection under Section 79 of the Information Technology Act, 2000 for social media platforms that use algorithms to rank, promote or suppress user content. Peer-to-peer messaging services that do not interfere with users' messages may be exempted.
Why in news
Background: Officials argue that a platform which curates content through algorithms is no longer a passive pipeline and plays an active role in what users see, so blanket immunity needs a relook. The proposal is at a preliminary stage, would need an amendment to the IT Act, and stakeholder consultation is planned. A separate proposal would let users ask platforms directly to remove deepfakes and non-consensual images about them.
Prelims pointers
- Section 79 of the IT Act gives intermediaries conditional immunity from liability for third-party content.
- The protection is lost if the intermediary initiates the transmission, selects the receiver, or modifies the information, or fails to follow due diligence.
- In Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015), the Supreme Court struck down Section 66A and read down Section 79 so that intermediaries must act on a court order or government notification.
- The IT (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021 set due diligence duties, including grievance officers. Significant social media intermediaries have extra obligations.
- Critics warn that removing immunity for algorithmic curation could push platforms to over-censor content through shadow-banning or reduced reach.
Mains angle
Algorithms decide what billions of people see, so treating platforms as neutral carriers is increasingly hard to justify, especially for deepfakes, child safety and misinformation. But excessive liability can make platforms remove lawful speech to avoid risk, chilling free expression under Article 19(1)(a). A graded, risk-based framework with clear standards and judicial oversight would balance accountability and free speech better than a blanket withdrawal.